Current:Home > Contact-usA Wisconsin ruling on Catholic Charities raises the bar for religious tax exemptions-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
A Wisconsin ruling on Catholic Charities raises the bar for religious tax exemptions
View
Date:2024-12-24 01:08:03
MADISON, Wis. (AP) — Exemptions that allow religious organizations to avoid paying Wisconsin’s unemployment tax don’t apply to a Catholic charitable organization because its on-the-ground operations aren’t primarily religious, a divided state Supreme Court ruled Thursday.
The outcome of the case, which drew attention and concern from religious groups around the country, raises the bar for all religions to show that their charity arms deserve such exemptions in the state.
The court ruled 4-3 that the Superior-based Catholic Charities Bureau and its subentities’ motivation to help older, disabled and low-income people stems from Catholic teachings but that its actual work is secular.
“In other words, they offer services that would be the same regardless of the motivation of the provider, a strong indication that the sub-entities do not ‘operate primarily for religious purposes,’” Justice Ann Walsh Bradley wrote for the majority.
Religious groups from around the country filed briefs in the case, including Catholic Conferences in Illinois, Iowa, Michigan and Minnesota, the American Islamic Congress, the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, the International Society for Krishna Consciousness, the Sikh Coalition, and the Jewish Coalition for Religious Liberty.
Eric Rassbach, vice president and senior counsel for the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, which represented the Catholic Charities Bureau, said the court got the case “dead wrong.”
“CCB is religious, whether Wisconsin recognizes that fact or not,” he said.
The firm did not immediately respond to an email inquiring about the possibility of an appeal to a federal court.
Wisconsin law requires to pay an unemployment tax that is used to fund benefits for workers who lose their jobs. The law exempts religious organizations from the tax.
Every Catholic diocese in Wisconsin has a Catholic Charities entity that serves as that diocese’s social ministry arm.
The Catholic Charities Bureau is the Superior diocese’s entity. The bureau manages nonprofit organizations that run more than 60 programs designed to help older or disabled people, children with special needs, low-income families, and people suffering from disasters, regardless of their religion, according to court documents.
The bureau and four of its subentities have been arguing in court for five years that the religious exemption from the unemployment tax should apply to them because they’re motivated by Catholic teachings that call for helping others.
A state appeals court this past February decided the subentities failed to show that their activities are motivated by religion. Judge Lisa Stark wrote that the subentities’ mission statements call for serving everyone, regardless of their religions.
As for the bureau itself, it has a clear religious motivation but isn’t directly involved in any religiously oriented activities, she wrote. The outcome might have been different, Stark added, if the church actually ran the bureau and its subentities. Their workers would then be considered church employees, she said.
The bureau and the subentities asked the Supreme Court to review that decision. But the court’s four-justice liberal majority upheld the appellate ruling on almost the same rationale.
“The record demonstrates that CCB and the sub-entities, which are organized as separate corporations apart from the church itself, neither attempt to imbue program participants with the Catholic faith nor supply any religious materials to program participants or employees,” Ann Walsh Bradley wrote.
Justice Rebecca Bradley, one of the court’s three conservative justices, began her dissent by quoting a Bible verse that calls for rendering unto God the things that are God’s. She accused the majority of rewriting the exemption statutes to deprive Catholic Charities of the exemption, “rendering unto the state that which the law says belongs to the church.”
“The majority’s misinterpretation also excessively entangles the government in spiritual affairs, requiring courts to determine what religious practices are sufficiently religious under the majority’s unconstitutional test,” Rebecca Bradley wrote. “The majority says secular entities provide charitable services, so such activities aren’t religious at all, even when performed by Catholic Charities.”
veryGood! (6)
Related
- Reese Witherspoon's Daughter Ava Phillippe Introduces Adorable New Family Member
- A rocket with a lunar landing craft blasts off on Russia’s first moon mission in nearly 50 years
- 50 Cent, Busta Rhymes celebrate generations of rappers ahead of hip-hop's milestone anniversary
- Police detain 18 people for storming pitch at Club América-Nashville SC Leagues Cup match
- Texas’ 90,000 DACA recipients can sign up for Affordable Care Act coverage — for now
- James Williams: From Academics to Crypto Visionary
- Target recall: 2.2 million Threshold candles recalled; at least 1 injured
- Zendaya Visits Mural Honoring Euphoria Costar Angus Cloud After His Death
- Tony Hinchcliffe refuses to apologize after calling Puerto Rico 'garbage' at Trump rally
- North Carolina woman wins $4 million in new scratch-off lottery game
Ranking
- Monument erected in Tulsa for victims of 1921 Race Massacre
- 3 dead after eating wild mushrooms at family lunch in Australia; woman under investigation
- Hip-hop at 50: A history of explosive musical and cultural innovation
- Will 'Red, White & Royal Blue' be your cup of tea?
- My Chemical Romance returns with ‘The Black Parade’ tour
- Everything to know about the new COVID variant Eris—and tools to protect yourself
- Gal Gadot enjoys 'messy' superspy life and being an Evil Queen: 'It was really juicy'
- Iran's leader vows to enforce mandatory dress code as women flout hijab laws
Recommendation
A $1 billion proposal is the latest plan to refurbish and save the iconic Houston Astrodome
The Journey of a Risk Dynamo
NOAA doubles the chances for a nasty Atlantic hurricane season due to hot ocean, tardy El Nino
AP-Week in Pictures: Aug. 3 - Aug. 10, 2023
Lost luggage? This new Apple feature will let you tell the airline exactly where it is.
LGBTQ+ people in Ethiopia blame attacks on their community on inciteful and lingering TikTok videos
Man cited for animal neglect after dog dies in triple-digit heat during Phoenix hike
Police investigate shooting at Nashville library that left 2 people wounded